I tend to be pretty passionate about the email marketing space, the best practices and the advice that experts publish. I find that the email marketers are hungry for information and it is our responsibility as experts to provide the best and most sound guidance and recommendations we can. So when I get a call from a client today about an article that ran in Email Marketing Reports yesterday questioning the purpose of subject lines I was intrigued. I am about 3 days behind in my newsletter reading, so I sifted through and found it. The actual article itself is short and sweet - stating that subject lines don’t matter as much as they used to.
So far - so good.
The subject line used to be the key to getting your message opened. Now - if your message makes the inbox, it is more likely that the from name coupled with the subject line are responsible for the open. However, this article links to an interesting blog post by a competitor stating that, “…in fact, the only thing that materially affected open rates was the sender: the name of the company or person in the “from” line.” It went on to say that the finding was based on, “an initial review of the [client] data. It’s quite possible that the full study might have uncovered some additional drivers of open rates. However, the initial review was so clear that we didn’t think it was worth completing the study.”
So follow me if you will, down the path of logic. This is stating that a fundamental component of email marketing is no longer relevant in the space based on an incomplete study? Hmmm…this is an opportune time for me to remind you to read between the lines. Not every statistic is validated or reliable.
Back to the topic at hand; I had to respond to my client’s questions and concerns as we have spent substantial time working through the subject line conundrum. And while we have found that the subject line length, the inclusion of specific words or personalization doesn’t necessarily drive a significant or reliable lift in conversion - the subject line itself is definitely a contributing factor.
If your recipients hate you or your brand - which they can determine by the from name, they are not likely going to open your message. But I can tell you, I get plenty of email from companies I do business with all the time and brands that I LOVE and just because Crate and Barrel landed in my inbox, does not mean I am going to open it up. But if the subject line indicates something that is relevant and timely to me - then open here I come!
What is the take away here? Yes, subject line has taken a hit as the major contributor to an open. But the message that has been over looked in that entire blog is that it isn’t the length of the subject line, or the inclusion of the word “Free” that drives the open - and it isn’t even the from name. It is getting the right message, to the right person at just the right time.
I close with a quote I once heard from a well respected expert in the industry, “You could write your offer on a cocktail napkin, in lipstick and still have an 80% chance of conversion - as long as it was handed to the right person at the right time.” I carry that with me every day and you should too.
Permanent link to this post (601 words, estimated 2:24 mins reading time)